I definitely made the batter too thick when I tried these but I grilled them anyway - making 6 smaller pancakes - and now I'm treating them like cookies. I have one for a snack if I'm hungry and it's very satisfying. I think that going forward, I would spoon the flours into measuring cups rather than dipping the cup into the flour to measure. I suspect that this packs the flour down too much causing me to use more than I need and making the batter too dry.